The Back Room with Andy Ostroy The Back Room with Andy Ostroy

Tara Setmayer Says "Please Dems Don't Blow It!": Trump, the Midterms, and the Fight to Save Democracy

Sep 19, 2026 · 1h 7m

Summary

Andy Ostroy and guest Tara Setmayer analyze the 2026 midterm landscape, noting that rising inflation and Trump’s erratic behavior are causing MAGA voters to defect. They discuss the Federal Reserve’s decision to raise interest rates, the Supreme Court’s rulings against Trump, and the urgent need for Democrats to avoid complacency. Setmayer advises using an "8 Mile" strategy to preemptively counter Republican fear-mongering while focusing on economic hardship and corruption.

Topics discussed

Welcome, intro, and call to action Fed rate hikes and Trump's political maneuvering Republican defections and midterm polling shifts Rising fuel costs and public anger at Trump MAGA Inc ads and the 2028 nomination race FBI hiring standards and Kash Patel hearing Court rulings, impeachment, and NYC issues Kennedy Center controversy and Trump's behavior Tara Setmayer intro: campaign strategy and urgency Voter sentiment in red states and key messages Trump's grip on the party and Republican distancing Maria Salazar's ad and nationalizing the election Women's issues and the '8 Mile' political strategy Democratic messaging and effective oversight hearings Critique of hearing tactics and media repetition Democratic internal dynamics and DSA candidates Populist messaging and governance concerns Senate races and constitutional violations Narrative setting and specific Senate candidates Closing: civic duty and accountability
Listen ad-free on Castria