The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL

Is the era of quarterback-driven success in the NFL over?

Jul 9, 2026 · 55m

Summary

Hosts Robert Mays, Dave Helman, and Derek Klassen debate whether the NFL’s quarterback-centric era has ended, citing recent Super Bowl wins by defense-first teams like the Seahawks and Eagles. They analyze how defensive schemes have evolved to neutralize offensive advantages, making elite defense a more viable path to a championship. The discussion concludes that while teams no longer need top-10 offenses, they still require competent quarterback play and explosive capabilities to succeed in the playoffs.

Topics discussed

Intro: Is the NFL entering a defense-first era? Defining the eras: From 2017 to the present Historical context: Rule changes and CBA impacts The shift: Why defense is catching up to offense Tactical shifts: Motion, formations, and defensive prep Case study: The Seahawks' run game and explosiveness Sam Darnold and the 'good enough' quarterback theory Revisiting the MVP quarterback necessity The Brady effect and historical Super Bowl winners Roster construction: Drafting vs. Free Agency Conclusion: Equilibrium and future outlook

More from The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL

Week 11 Preview: Battle For NFC's 1 seed, Jaguars new defense & stopping Jahmyr Gibbs
Nov 20, 2026
Texans trample flailing Colts 26-3
Nov 20, 2026
Blitz-happy defenses, the “perfect modern offense” & more trends from this season
Nov 19, 2026
Updated top 50: Xavier Gilliam & Zereoue Williams rise, Cam Coleman falls
Nov 18, 2026
Week 10 Hangover: Rams pony (personnel) up, Bills identity, Mendoza's ups & downs
Nov 17, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria