The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL

Are coaches more valuable than non-QB players in today's NFL?

May 18, 2026

Summary

Hosts Robert Mays, Dave Richard, and Derek Shapka analyze listener questions in this Mailbag Monday episode. They debate Baker Mayfield’s value to the Buccaneers, weighing his performance against contract implications and potential successors. The trio also discusses head coaches Sean Payton and Frank Reich voluntarily relinquishing play-calling duties. Finally, they explore whether elite coaches like Sean McVay are more valuable than top-tier non-quarterback players.

Topics discussed

Introduction and mailbag setup Baker Mayfield analysis: value, contract, and future Carolina Panthers: Brad Idzik taking over play-calling Hypothetical draft: Coaches vs. Players Best NFL draft picks of all time Rams' use of fullback Kyle Juszczyk Outro and closing remarks

More from The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL

Week 11 Preview: Battle For NFC's 1 seed, Jaguars new defense & stopping Jahmyr Gibbs
Nov 20, 2026
Texans trample flailing Colts 26-3
Nov 20, 2026
Blitz-happy defenses, the “perfect modern offense” & more trends from this season
Nov 19, 2026
Updated top 50: Xavier Gilliam & Zereoue Williams rise, Cam Coleman falls
Nov 18, 2026
Week 10 Hangover: Rams pony (personnel) up, Bills identity, Mendoza's ups & downs
Nov 17, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria