The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL

Are Colin Simmons and Charlie Becker locks for the first round?

Oct 21, 2026 · 1h 2m

Summary

The Athletic Football Show hosts a detailed evaluation of Arch Manning’s struggles at Texas, debating whether his inconsistent decision-making and lack of confidence signal a ceiling or a fixable issue. The discussion expands to the 2027 quarterback class, analyzing prospects like Darian Mensah, Drew Mestemacher, and Trinidad Chambers while weighing the impact of NIL money on their draft decisions. The hosts also highlight risers like Connor Wegman and argue that despite early concerns, the class remains deep with multiple potential first-rounders.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Discover Cash Back Card Sponsor: Gab Kids Phone Introduction and guest welcome Arch Manning's inconsistent performance vs Florida Analysis of Manning's decision-making and processing Comparison to Quinn Ewers and Texas uncertainty Specific play breakdowns and accuracy concerns Manning's NFL draft projection and confidence issues Offensive adjustments and potential transfer rumors Manning's talent vs consistency and season outlook Sponsors: The Athletic, US Bank, Shopify, ButcherBox 2027 QB class overview and top prospects Darian Mensah's performance and Miami's defense Mestemaker's decision to return to school Dante Moore's size concerns and NFL comparison NIL discussions and draft value for QBs Rising prospect: Connor Wegman Mestemaker's reckless plays and high-stakes games Sponsors: Scribe and Onnit AlphaBrain Green Room: Colin Simmons (Texas Edge) Green Room: Charlie Becker (Indiana WR) Tennessee's defensive line and Xavier Gilliam BYU's Cade Ulave and upcoming games Closing remarks and sponsor: Metro by T-Mobile

More from The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL

Week 11 Preview: Battle For NFC's 1 seed, Jaguars new defense & stopping Jahmyr Gibbs
Nov 20, 2026
Texans trample flailing Colts 26-3
Nov 20, 2026
Blitz-happy defenses, the “perfect modern offense” & more trends from this season
Nov 19, 2026
Updated top 50: Xavier Gilliam & Zereoue Williams rise, Cam Coleman falls
Nov 18, 2026
Week 10 Hangover: Rams pony (personnel) up, Bills identity, Mendoza's ups & downs
Nov 17, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria