That Chapter Podcast That Chapter Podcast

Ep.177 - The True Story of the Perron Family Haunting

Jun 8, 2026 · 47m

Summary

Hosts Mike and Keith review *Scream 7* negatively while praising the horror-comedy series *Widow’s Bay*. They then detail the Perrin family haunting, which inspired *The Conjuring*, discussing the involvement of Ed and Lorraine Warren. The episode examines the alleged witch Bathsheba Sherman and the historical inaccuracies surrounding the case, including the true identity of Mrs. John Arnold.

Topics discussed

Intro: Keith's bathroom delay and raspy voice Keith's knee brace and hat collection Spooky encounter with a floating head Review of Scream 7 and deep fake tech Recommendation for the TV show Widow's Bay Ed and Lorraine Warren and psychic research history Warren's famous cases and The Conjuring movies The Perrin family moves to Rhode Island Initial paranormal activity and benevolent spirits Escalation: Demonic smells and threats Violent attacks and the Warrens' involvement The legend of Bathsheba Sherman the witch Debunking Bathsheba's history and timeline The true identity of Mrs. John Arnold The failed exorcism and family's departure Subsequent owners and the house's current status Andrea Perrin's books and final thoughts
Listen ad-free on Castria