The Disturbing Case of Justin Michael
Summary
This episode details the 2014 murder of Justin Michael in Grimes, Iowa, by his coworker and ex-boyfriend of his fiancée, David Moffat. After Angie broke up with Moffat to marry Michael, Moffat stalked the couple and meticulously planned to kill Michael while framing Angie’s other ex, Andy Wegener. Moffat’s elaborate scheme unraveled when he crashed his car near the crime scene, leaving behind planted evidence that linked him to the murder. He was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life without parole.
Topics discussed
Introduction to Grimes, Iowa
Victim Justin Michael and his engagement
The murder night and 911 call
Initial investigation and suspect motives
Angie's ex-boyfriends Andy and David
David Moffat's car crash and evidence
The frame-up scheme against Andy Wegener
Uncovering the fake IDs and planning
David's obsession and workplace proximity
Trial, conviction, and final thoughts
Listen ad-free on Castria