The Strange Case of Desiree Sunford
Summary
This episode details the 2013 murder of Desiree Sunford in Yakima, Washington, and the subsequent investigation into her husband Scott and his friend Paige Blades. After Scott’s suspicious behavior and a complex love triangle emerged, Paige implicated Marty Grismer, a coworker obsessed with her, claiming he killed Desiree to help them. Despite inconsistencies and lack of motive, Grismer was convicted via an Alford plea for second-degree murder, though the narrator suggests he may have been a patsy for Scott and Paige.
Topics discussed
Introduction to Yakima and the Sunford burglary
Discovery of Desiree's murder and initial investigation
Scott's suspicious behavior and the revelation of Paige
Investigating the alleged threesome and conflicting stories
Anonymous tip identifies Marty Grismer as the killer
Paige's motive and Marty's alleged confession
Wired recording and the discovery of the murder weapon
Marty's arrest, plea deal, and lingering doubts
Listen ad-free on Castria