Swindled Swindled

Rerun: The Creamery (Blue Bell)

Sep 24, 2026 · 51m

Summary

This episode of Swindled details the 2015 Blue Bell Listeria outbreak, which killed three people and sickened others after the company failed to address known sanitation hazards. Former CEO Paul Kruse is accused of concealing positive test results and delaying recalls to protect sales, leading to a guilty plea by the company and a $19.3 million fine. Although Kruse faced federal fraud charges, his trial ended in a mistrial due to a deadlocked jury. The story also covers a separate 2022 Listeria outbreak linked to Big Olaf Creamery, highlighting ongoing food safety failures in the ice cream …

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Progressive Insurance Sponsor: Levi's and Content Warning Kristen Hopkins' pregnancy and Listeria symptoms Big Olaf Creamery linked to Listeria outbreak Regulatory delays and Big Olaf plant shutdown Lawsuits against Big Olaf Creamery Sponsors: Zenni and Progressive Sponsor: Dupixent for EOE History and growth of Blue Bell Creameries Paul Kruse joins Blue Bell and expansion 2015 Listeria outbreak discovery and deaths Blue Bell recall and David Shockley's case Public reaction and community support for Blue Bell Cleanup efforts and employee reassurances Sponsors: Acorns and Progressive Sponsor: Dupixent Mass layoffs and Blue Bell's return to shelves Investigation reveals long-standing sanitation failures Criticism of corporate negligence and DOJ investigation Sponsors: Progressive and Dupixent Subsequent recalls and shareholder lawsuits The 'Lufkin Licker' viral video incident DOJ charges against Blue Bell and Paul Kruse Trial proceedings and mistrial outcome Montage of other ice cream Listeria recalls Outro, Patreon support, and final sponsors
Listen ad-free on Castria