Stuff You Should Know Stuff You Should Know

SYSK Gets Weird Playlist: Mermaids: Not a real thing

Sep 18, 2026 · 41m

Summary

Hosts Josh Clark and Charles Bryant explore the history and mythology of mermaids, debunking modern sightings as manatees or hoaxes. They discuss ancient folklore from Babylon to West Africa, highlighting the dual nature of these creatures as both alluring and deadly. The episode also covers the dark ending of Hans Christian Andersen’s original "The Little Mermaid" and the 1990 satirical scientific paper on mermaid biology. Finally, the hosts examine the reality of professional mermaid performers and the viral "Mermaids" mockumentary that fooled many viewers.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: McCormick, Vivart, and Brilliant Episode intro: Mermaids and the Splash movie Pop culture chat: Daryl Hannah and Neil Young Band nostalgia: Ramones and Rolling Stone article Time travel hypotheticals and doctored photos Modern mermaid tourism in Kiryat Yam, Israel Critique of mermaid folklore and misogyny Ancient history: Nereids and Poseidon's origins The Little Mermaid: Hans Christian Andersen's version Mermaids as omens and sirens in folklore Sponsors: Apple Business and Eating Interrupted Sirens vs. Mermaids and the goddess Atergatis German Nixes and the duality of water spirits Historical sightings: Explorers and manatees Columbus and John Smith's mermaid accounts Sponsor: Eating Interrupted podcast Sponsor: Wayfair home goods Carl Bance's 1907 mermaid anatomy theory Discovery Channel's 'Mermaids' mockumentary Historical cases: Edam and the 'Mermaid' of 1430 Professional mermaids and eco-activism Outro: Reviews, social media, and jingles Sponsor: Lingo Kids app Sponsor: Vivart rare disease stories
Listen ad-free on Castria