Pressie: The Serpentine Cryptid of Lake Superior
May 29, 2026 · 1h 17m
Summary
Hosts Matt, Noel, and Ben investigate the Lake Superior cryptid known as Pressy, exploring its roots in Ojibwe mythology as the Mishipeshu, or underwater panther. They analyze historical accounts, including an 1886 newspaper story about prospectors encountering a tentacled creature, while debating whether these tales reflect genuine biological anomalies or cultural storytelling. The episode examines the vast, unexplored depths of the Great Lakes as a potential habitat for unknown life forms.
Topics discussed
Intro, Virgin Voyages ad, and episode setup
Introducing Pressy and the Great Lakes
Geography and history of the Great Lakes
Lake ecology, algae, and ancient submerged civilizations
Ojibwe mythology: Mishipeshu and the underwater panther
European colonization and early reports of aquatic monsters
The 1886 prospector story: Green light and giant eye
Analyzing the prospector tale and TV tropes
Modern sightings, photos, and the 'Nessie of the North'
Scientific explanations: Catfish and folklore
The Lake Sturgeon as the likely culprit
Modern search tech, listener contact info, and outro
Listen ad-free on Castria