Possessed By The Devil: The Story of Latoya Ammons
May 6, 2026 · 1h 17m
Summary
Hosts Matt, Noel, and Ben investigate the infamous 2011 Gary, Indiana "demon house" case involving the Ammons family. They detail escalating paranormal claims, including levitation and violent behavior, which led to police involvement, child services intervention, and exorcisms. The episode balances these supernatural accounts with skeptical perspectives, exploring potential psychological or environmental explanations for the family's traumatic experiences.
Topics discussed
Intro: Paranormal topics and the Gary, Indiana demon house
Ads: Alienware, UnitedHealthcare, Ride or Die, Cosentix
The Ammons family moves in and encounters insect swarms
Escalation: Footsteps, moving objects, and shoe rituals
Alleged levitation and violent behavior in the children
Medical skepticism and police Captain Austin's investigation
Exorcisms, digging up the yard, and CPS involvement
Ads: Postpartum depression, Ride or Die, NFL Fan Fest
Skeptical analysis: Mass psychogenic illness and tantrums
Critique of Zach Bacon's documentary 'Demon House'
Documentary editing tricks and the grandmother's backward walk
House demolition, Netflix series, and family custody outcome
Outro: Listener mail, Bigfoot conspiracy, and final ads
Listen ad-free on Castria