Straight White American Jesus Straight White American Jesus

The Sunday Interview: "Women Are a Snare"": Purity Culture and the Scandal at Wheaton

Oct 11, 2026 · 49m

Summary

Host Brad Onishi interviews Wheaton College alumni Andrea Sorensen Hamler, Christy Hemphill, and Erica Roland to discuss a decades-long cover-up of sexual abuse by administrator Dennis Massaro. The guests detail how the university protected its reputation by concealing the assaults, allowing Massaro to continue accessing campus and later exploiting refugees in Turkey. They critique President Philip Ryken’s history of failing to address abuse and analyze how evangelical gender norms and a lack of proper consent training create a culture of silence. The episode highlights the systemic failure…

Topics discussed

Intro: AI infrastructure and Bloomberg ad HomeServe ad and transition to Wheaton College Guest introductions and overview of the controversy Details on the administrator's abuse and dismissal Allegations of abuse in Turkey and institutional silence Student experiences and the ex-wife's warnings President Reichen's history with Paul Jones Institutional reputation vs. student safety Gender dynamics and the 'sincerity' defense Campus culture, boundaries, and reporting barriers Plaid ad and Bloomberg ad Theological views on male sexuality and control Wheaton as a case study in evangelical abuse Toxic themes in marriage and relationship teachings Community covenant and consent confusion Title IX reporting failures and low numbers The danger of 'assumption of safety' in churches Parent perspectives and the broader cultural impact Outro and Bloomberg ad Mild at Heart: Masculinity and purity culture Anthropic ad
Listen ad-free on Castria