Straight White American Jesus Straight White American Jesus

The Sunday Interview: Matthew Taylor on Risking Everything to Confront Christian Supremacy

Oct 18, 2026 · 52m

Summary

Theologian Matt Taylor discusses his new book, *Defying Tyrants*, arguing that Christian supremacy is a deeper threat than nationalism and that the "Antichrist" is a plural concept describing Christians who abuse power in Jesus's name. Taylor explains how the ideology of Christendom has historically justified violence and imperialism, contrasting it with Jesus’s subversive, non-coercive kingdom. He also shares his personal story of being fired from an interfaith institute for refusing to abandon the manuscript, framing his continued publication as a necessary act of democratic and theologic…

Topics discussed

Sponsors and introduction Guest introduction: Matt and his new book Motivation for writing and shift in perspective Propaganda as theological language Challenging Christian supremacy in personal contexts Personal cost: firing from interfaith institute Reaction to the firing and political context Defining Christian supremacy vs. nationalism Historical roots: Imperialism and white supremacy Theological framework of the book The Antichrist figure in Christian history Scriptural analysis of Antichrist texts Plural Antichrists and eschatological ethics Sponsors and transition Manifestation of Antichrist in Christian supremacy Johannine community and schism Abuse of power in the name of Christ Explaining Christian awfulness and the No True Scotsman fallacy Defining Christianity vs. Christendom Christendom, Constantine, and the Crusades Sponsors and transition Rejecting Christian supremacy: The logic of the Kingdom Why publish despite the risks? Consequences and duty Closing remarks and call to action Sponsors
Listen ad-free on Castria