Story Time Society Story Time Society

Am I Losing It… Or Are They Cheating? (With Updates) | Reading Reddit Stories

Aug 17, 2026 · 33m

Summary

Host Jamie discusses two cheating stories on Storytime Society. First, a 20-year-old woman breaks up with her boyfriend after he prioritizes a female friend who clearly has a crush on him. Second, a man discovers his fiancée’s ex-boyfriend claims they are still intimate, leading to a tense confrontation about trust and potential stalking.

Topics discussed

Intro and episode theme: cheating stories Story 1: Boyfriend hanging out with girl who likes him Text transcript: Argument over boundaries and jealousy Host reaction: Immaturity and rebounding behavior Update 1: Apology and continued conflict via text Breakup: Boyfriend admits to hanging out with her Host rant: High school drama and mermaid story Update 2: In-person confrontation and breakup The other girl's aggressive text message Final update: Blocking the ex and moving on Story 2: Fiance's secret boyfriend contacts OP Text transcript: Secret boyfriend's claims and photos Host reaction: Cultural context and phone checking Update: Confronting the fiance about the ex Final thoughts: Stalker vibes and trust issues Outro and sponsor message
Listen ad-free on Castria