Story Time Society Story Time Society

AITAH Reddit Stories That Took an Unexpected Turn (With Updates) | Reading Reddit Stories

Aug 4, 2026 · 44m

Summary

Host Jamie reads two "Am I the Asshole" stories. The first involves a bride disinviting a groomsmen with green hair for refusing to wear a wig for green-screen photos, which escalates into stalking and a restraining order. The second features a student leaving her landlord after being blamed for not caring for six dogs while her roommate was hospitalized. Jamie critiques the drama and offers commentary on the outcomes.

Topics discussed

Nesquik chocolate milk advertisement Backstory: Meeting fiancé and ex's past drama Fantasy wedding plans and green screen photo booth Conflict: Guest's green hair ruins photos Disinviting the guest and initial fallout Hosts' initial reactions and judgment Update: Stalking, threats, and police involvement Mental health context and restraining order Final update: Simplified wedding and green screen success Disturbing photos found and baby announcement New story: Roommate drama over dog sitting Moving out and lease inspection disputes Reflections on living with a landlord Nesquik chocolate milk advertisement Host's anxiety around authority figures
Listen ad-free on Castria