S10 E6: Sebastién
Apr 13, 2026 · 52m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
In this episode, David Ridgen re-interviews Sebastian Furland-Smith to clarify inconsistencies regarding the timeline of Jackie’s disappearance, specifically focusing on a new witness who places Sebastian at a restaurant hours before Jackie’s last known movements. The discussion covers conflicting accounts of their final argument, the role of cadaver dogs, and Sebastian’s ongoing struggles with depression and PTSD. The episode highlights the difficulty of reconstructing events amidst memory gaps and contradictory testimonies from locals and family members.
Topics discussed
Introduction and Costa Rican greetings
Investigator's return and new questions
Sebastian apologizes for previous coldness
Navigating rumors and circumstantial evidence
Sebastian's depression and social judgment
Arrest of OIJ investigator Ulysses Guevara
Reopening the case and police interactions
Case archived and phone re-examination
Conflicting accounts of the August 17th fight
Sebastian describes Jackie's aggressive behavior
Sebastian's alibi and Jackie's departure
Theories on Jackie's potential new relationship
Jackie's flirtatious behavior and suspicions
Sebastian's movements on the night of disappearance
Inconsistencies in dinner and whereabouts accounts
Difficulty recalling specific timing details
Verifying Sebastian's presence at the Palms
Searching for Deanna McIntosh's testimony
Discussion of backyard garden and police digging
Jackie's past suicidal statements and patterns
Sister Candice's account of verbal abuse
Sebastian denies participating in verbal abuse
Impact of moving to Costa Rica on Jackie's health
Sebastian's role in Jackie's increased stress
Sebastian's suicidal thoughts and calls for help
Sebastian's PTSD and sleep issues
PTSD effects on memory and public comfort
Account of Jackie falling during a door block
Sebastian's perceived honesty and past arguments
Incident of Sebastian throwing phone and driving off
Previous instances of Jackie leaving and returning
Discrepancy regarding surveillance camera removal
Sebastian's current living situation and safety concerns
Verification of camera footage and neighbor sightings
Cadaver dog detection and blood evidence
Details of blood test and dog alert
Lab report limitations and Sebastian's blood
Sponsor segment for Citizens Bank
Explanations for Sebastian's leg scars
Dog scratch injury and lack of owner
Clarification on relationship with Spanish teacher
Deanna McIntosh's account of seeing Sebastian
Deanna's timeline and husband's corroboration
Jackie's earlier departure and walking route
Jackie's multiple departures and search efforts
Neighbor's suspicion and lack of police report
Laura's lack of memory of the evening
Sebastian's vague recollection of returning home
Timing discrepancies regarding Jackie's storming off
Jackie's presence at the park and receipts
Sebastian's inability to recall precise sequence
Sebastian's past suicidal ideation and recovery
Sebastian's reflection on aggravating Jackie's condition
Nature of Jackie and Sebastian's relationship
Unresolved questions and investigator's belief
Suicide crisis hotline information
Production credits and team acknowledgments
Promotion of CBC True Crime YouTube channel
Link to more CBC podcasts
More from Someone Knows Something
Listen ad-free on Castria