I Fear We're Not Reacting Enough | Reading Reddit Stories
Jun 6, 2026
Summary
Shane, Courtney, and Arash host a "Smosh Reads Reddit Stories" episode themed around overreacting. They discuss three tales: a woman annoyed by her boyfriend’s morning kisses, a wife suspicious of a sex toy package sent to her home, and a nanny uncomfortable with her employers having sex. The hosts analyze the validity of each reaction, offering humorous commentary and relationship advice.
Topics discussed
Intro, sponsors, and setting the stage for Reddit stories
Boyfriend wakes girlfriend up to say goodbye
Accidental adult toy delivery and cheating suspicions
Nanny confronts parents about having sex during work hours
Guy sends explicit text meant for AI to new date
Girlfriend overreacts to late birthday text
Listen ad-free on Castria