I Think We're UNDERreacting | Reading Reddit Stories
Oct 3, 2026 · 1h 15m
Summary
In this episode of Smosh Reads Reddit Stories, hosts Shane, Trevor, and Jared discuss posts from the "Am I Overreacting" subreddit. They analyze a friend discovering their fiancé’s new partner trashed the engagement ring online, an 18-year-old woman refusing a coworker’s breakfast demands, and a daughter feeling unwelcome in her family’s lake house due to her father’s girlfriend. The hosts also read a story about a mother refusing to name her newborn after her husband’s deceased best friend, debating the validity of each person's reactions.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Alma for therapist billing
Intro: Overreacting vs underreacting
Story: Friend's fiancée badmouthing on Reddit
Discussion: Social media consequences
Conclusion: Tell the friend about the post
Story: Coworker expects daily breakfast
Sponsors: Rocket Money and BetMGM
Discussion: Age gap and entitlement in office
Story: Girlfriend's overbearing hospitality
Story: Husband wants to name baby after secret friend
Update: Confronting husband about Claire
Story: Girlfriend's parents lock all doors
Story: Boyfriend sends 'boring girlfriend' meme
Listen ad-free on Castria