Digging Up Reddit's Past | Reading Reddit Stories
Oct 17, 2026 · 1h 9m
Summary
Smosh hosts read and react to a mix of classic and prehistoric Reddit stories, starting with a 2020 post about a man whose girlfriend buried their beans in the woods during the pandemic. They also discuss a viral "ultimate lay" thread featuring a famous comment about a deceased wife, a bizarre tale of a woman moving in with her ex-boyfriend's father, and a passionate 2014 rant from r/grilled cheese about the proper definition of a sandwich.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: BetMGM and Culligan Purity
Intro: Prehistoric Reddit and cave jokes
History of Am I the Asshole subreddit
Story: Girlfriend buried beans in the woods
Sponsor: ZocDoc doctor appointments
Story: 'I also choose this guy's dead wife'
Story: Moving in with ex-boyfriend's dad
Story: Grilled cheese vs. melt terminology
Sponsors: Quince and Alma therapy billing
Story: Teacher's rant about student Kevin
Story: Post-it notes and carbon monoxide
Story: Reasons my wife is crying
Outro and Nissan Rogue sponsor
Listen ad-free on Castria