Small Town Murder Small Town Murder

The Ax Murder Zombie - Delmar, New York

Sep 10, 2026 · 3h 3m

Summary

This episode of Small Town Murder explores the 2004 ax murder in Delmar, New York, a quiet suburb near Albany. Hosts James Petrigall and Jimmy Wman introduce the Porco family, highlighting the seemingly perfect life of lawyer Peter and speech pathologist Joan, and their sons. The narrative focuses on the younger son, Christopher, whose fabricated persona as a wealthy student, history of theft, and financial frauds foreshadow the violent crime that would eventually shatter the community's safety.

Topics discussed

Introduction to the Delmar, NY ax murder case Patreon promotion and show guidelines Overview of Delmar, NY and local demographics Local events and police force capabilities Backgrounds of Peter and Joan Porco Christopher Porco's early life and education Christopher's fraud, loans, and family conflicts The murder scene and Peter's death Joan's survival and initial police response Analysis of the 6-hour police interrogation Interrogation details: finances and alibi Psychological assessment and interrogation critique Forensic evidence and physical clues Indictment, bail, and pre-trial publicity Trial arguments and defense strategy Verdict and subsequent appeals Legal disputes and Christopher's current status Host opinions and closing credits
Listen ad-free on Castria