Stormy, Deadly Night - Selma, North Carolina
Summary
Hosts James Petrigall and Jimmy Wman discuss the 1989 murder of 69-year-old Leland Grice in Selma, North Carolina. The episode details how two young men, Franklin Howell and Gordon Marlow, lured a neighbor into driving them to the victim's trailer while huffing lacquer thinner. The pair then robbed and shot Grice in the back of the head, with the driver later providing a full confession to detectives. The hosts also promote upcoming live shows and their Patreon content.
Topics discussed
Intro and upcoming live show dates
Patreon promotion and show preview
Introduction to Selma, North Carolina
Local reviews and community events
Discussion of local beauty pageants
Context: June 1989 pop culture and music
Background on victims Leland and Ruby Grice
The night of the murder and discovery
Forensic details and initial investigation
John Horton's testimony: The setup
The drive: Lacquer thinner and the plan
The crime: Jumping from the moving truck
Arrests and evidence discovery
Plea deals and DA controversy
Trial strategy and hearsay objections
Horton's testimony on confessions
Sentencing and appeals process
Legal arguments on counsel and mitigation
Family background and final thoughts
Outro and call to action
Listen ad-free on Castria