Savage Murder & Strange Milkshakes - Arab, Alabama
Summary
This episode of Small Town Murder explores the 1990 murder of Kathy Shears in Arab, Alabama, a town with a history of racial tension and a unique name origin. Hosts James Petrigallo and Jimmy Wisman detail the victim's life, her marriage to Randall Pagett, and his long-term affair with neighbor Judy Bagwell, who exhibited obsessive behavior. The narrative covers the couple's separation, Randall's suspicious trip to Florida with Bagwell on the day Kathy went missing, and the subsequent investigation that initially seemed straightforward due to DNA evidence. The hosts also provide background …
Topics discussed
Intro: The murder in Arab, Alabama
Patreon promotion and comedy disclaimer
Listener mail and local history of Arab
Town demographics and local amenities
Housing market and local flora
Background on Randall and Judy Pagett
Family dynamics and the affair begins
Judy's obsessive behavior and replica bedrooms
Kathy discovers the affair and confrontation
The night of the murder and discovery
Forensic evidence and police investigation
Randall's arrest and financial troubles
DNA evidence and early trial proceedings
Trial: Jury selection and expert testimony
Trial: Defense arguments and witness testimony
Trial: Emotional appeals and family testimony
Verdict, sentencing, and death row context
Life on death row and first appeals
New trial preparation and defense strategy
Retrial: Judy's testimony and new evidence
Retrial: Closing arguments and jury deliberation
Acquittal and post-trial events
Compensation, media, and personal aftermath
Outro, shoutouts, and credits
Listen ad-free on Castria