Guilty Google Search Murder - Winchester, Indiana
Summary
Hosts James Petrigall and Jimmy Wisman discuss the 2018 murder of David Brumley in Winchester, Indiana, who was found suffocated in his home. The episode details the investigation into his death and the prime suspect, Monty Cook, a childhood friend with a history of arson and kidnapping conspiracy charges. The hosts review Cook’s criminal past, including a $7.5 million factory fire, before analyzing the evidence linking him to Brumley’s homicide.
Topics discussed
Intro, live show updates, and Patreon promotion
Introduction to Winchester, Indiana
Town history, glass industry, and 2024 tornado
Local reviews and the Hawaiian Steel Guitar Festival
Introducing David Brumley and his prized Mustang
Monty Cook's 2003 arson of the MasterCraft factory
Cook's jailhouse kidnapping plot and 35-year sentence
Discovery of David Brumley's body in Nov 2018
Police investigation and identification of person of interest
Analysis of Cook's internet search history
Theft of funds and flight to Nevada
Arrest in Kingman, Arizona and robbery of hitchhiker
Trial, circumstantial evidence, and 64-year sentence
Appeal rejected and projected release date
Conclusion, listener feedback, and next episode preview
Listen ad-free on Castria