Slow Burn Slow Burn

Decoder Ring | The State of Chocolate Is Dark

Nov 18, 2026 · 42m

Summary

Features writer Rachel Handler investigates a viral controversy sparked by Brad Reese, who accused Hershey of altering the recipe for Reese's Cups. Handler explores the rise of "compound" chocolate, ingredient changes, and the impact of rising cocoa costs on product quality. Through a blind taste test comparing modern Reese's to recreated vintage versions, she finds the current product tastes inferior, revealing a broader story about corporate cost-cutting and the erosion of nostalgic consumer experiences.

Topics discussed

Intro: Rachel's chocolate taste crisis Nostalgia vs. reality: The Snow Caps experience Brad Reese's LinkedIn accusation against Hershey Show intro and the 'Chocolate Conspiracy' premise The shared experience of changing candy tastes Brad Reese's whistleblower stance and Hershey's silence History of chocolate: From cacao to solid bars Industrialization and the acquisition of Reese's Compound chocolate: Definition and legal standards Brad's packaging evidence and Hershey's pivot Hershey's response and the 'chocolatey' label trick Ingredient changes: PGPR, TBHQ, and the COVID loophole Cocoa price surge and the subjectivity of taste Recreating vintage Reese's with food scientist Beth The blind taste test: Rachel's results and doubts Brad Reese's taste test and the Ozempic factor The dual blame: Corporate changes and human memory Confronting Hershey: The 'evolved' recipe interview Conclusion: Inshittification and the loss of joy Outro and call to action

More from Slow Burn

Presenting: The Sporkful | Does The World Need A Better Tomato?
Nov 4, 2026
Decoder Ring | The Spooky Saga of the Icelandic Dracula
Oct 29, 2026
Decoder Ring | Clown Panic (Encore)
Oct 21, 2026
Decoder Ring | Gandhi Never Said “Be the Change”
Oct 14, 2026
Decoder Ring | McGruff Takes a Bite Out of Crime, Part 2 (Encore)
Aug 26, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria