Becoming Justice Gorsuch | 2. The Stolen Seat
Summary
This episode of Slow Burn Plus examines how Neil Gorsuch’s strict textualist philosophy, influenced by Antonin Scalia, shaped his rise to the Supreme Court. Host Susan Matthews details the 2016 Senate blockade of Merrick Garland, Gorsuch’s controversial “frozen trucker” dissent, and his surprising liberal ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County. The discussion highlights how Gorsuch’s performative civility masked a consistent, often conservative legal agenda that has impacted American jurisprudence.
Topics discussed
Recalling Justice Scalia's death and Mark Stern's reaction
Scalia's influence on Gorsuch and the rise of originalism
The blockade of Merrick Garland's nomination
Gorsuch's aggressive courtroom style and the frozen trucker case
Gorsuch's nomination and his long-standing conservative agenda
The strategy behind Gorsuch's mild-mannered confirmation hearings
Gorsuch's early tenure and shift in judicial demeanor
The Bostock ruling: Textualism protecting LGBTQ+ rights
Gorsuch's record on trans rights and the tariff case
SCOTUS credibility crisis and Gorsuch's public defense
Listen ad-free on Castria