Shamiya Todd
Summary
This episode details the 2021 murder of 18-year-old Shania James by Shamaya Todd, Shania’s boyfriend Christopher Mitchell’s ex-wife. The hosts explore how Mitchell manipulated both young women, leading to a violent confrontation where Todd shot James during a Father’s Day visit. Todd pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter and was sentenced to three to eight years in prison. The discussion critiques Mitchell’s predatory behavior and the legal outcomes for all parties involved.
Topics discussed
Intro and Quince bedding sponsorship
Welcome to Sisters Who Kill Men
Shamaya Todd's background and relationship with Christopher
Abuse, isolation, and the breakup
Shania James' background and grief over her father
Shania moves to Vegas and meets Christopher online
Shania's infatuation and behavioral changes
Conflict over Christopher's ex-wife and kids
Sponsorships: Chime, Shopify, and SmileSet
The Father's Day trip and escalating arguments
The shooting and conflicting 911 calls
Police arrival and discovery of Shania's body
Crime scene evidence and family reaction
Shamaya's initial statement blaming Christopher
Sponsorships: Zeni Optical, Rula, Whatnot, Minimalist
GSR tests and Shamaya's shifting story
Autopsy results, trial, and sentencing
Family grief and the hosts' critique of Christopher
I Ain't Do It segment: Analyzing the crime
Shamaya's release and listener reviews
Outro and social media plugs
Listen ad-free on Castria