Andrea Jackson
Jul 10, 2026 · 50m
Summary
Hosts Marah and Tez detail the 1983 murder of Jacksonville Officer Gary Bevel by Andrea Jackson, who shot him after he arrested her for a false vandalism report. The episode covers her violent escape, attempted murder of a taxi driver, and eventual arrest. It highlights her lengthy legal battle, where multiple death sentences were overturned due to procedural errors and claims of battered woman syndrome, resulting in a life sentence.
Topics discussed
Introduction and Andrea Jackson's background
The false police report and car vandalism
Officer Gary Bevel's biography and life
The confrontation and shooting of Officer Bevel
Fleeing to a friend's house and hiding
Community reaction and neighbor fears
Sponsorship: Quince and Baskin Lather
Sponsorship: FX's The Show
The taxi cab incident and second shooting attempt
Arrest at ex-husband's apartment and charges
Police press conference and search policy debate
Memorial service for Officer Bevel
First trial, verdict, and death sentence
Appeals, retrials, and psychiatric arguments
Sponsorship: Shopify, Thrive Market, LifeLock
Final appeals and Judge Moran's decision
Sentence commutation and current status
Hosts' retrospective: 'But if I did' analysis
Sponsorship: StreetEasy, Sustain Pro, EarnIn
Discussion on motive, family, and future
Listener mail, socials, and final sponsors
Listen ad-free on Castria