Phantom Of The Neighborhood - Acme, Washington
Summary
Hosts James Petrigallo and Jimmy Wissman discuss the 1989 murder of Amanda Stavik in Acme, Washington, blending true crime with comedy. They detail Mandy’s athletic life, her family’s tragic history in Alaska, and her disappearance while jogging near the Nooksack River. The episode covers the immediate search efforts, including a human tracker, and the discovery of her dog returning alone, setting the stage for the investigation into her brutal death.
Topics discussed
Introduction and show housekeeping
Comedian banter and show philosophy
Acme, Washington geography and demographics
Local music scene and property crime stats
Mandy Stavik's background and daily life
The disappearance on Thanksgiving 1989
Initial search efforts and forensic challenges
Discovery of the body in the river
Autopsy findings and timeline reconstruction
Community reaction and local context
Funeral, memorial, and local history
Early suspects and DNA investigation
Long-term investigation and reward fund
2009 case reopening and new leads
Tim Bass profile and behavioral evidence
DNA collection from Tim Bass
Forensic analysis and legal challenges
Trial, verdict, and sentencing
Outro, credits, and listener shoutouts
Listen ad-free on Castria