Short Wave Short Wave

Is your favorite crime show rooted in fake science?

Oct 30, 2026 · 14m

Summary

Host Emily Kwong and Chris Fabricant of the Innocence Project discuss how "junk science" techniques, such as hair microscopy and bite mark analysis, have contributed to wrongful convictions. They examine the "CSI effect" and legal precedents that allow flawed forensic evidence to persist in courtrooms. The episode highlights the need for stricter validation standards and blind testing to prevent bias and ensure scientific rigor in criminal justice.

Topics discussed

Intro: Mattress Firm ad and host introduction The gap between TV forensics and reality Chris Fabricant's background and the 2009 NAS report The rise of 'junk science' and wrongful convictions Episode overview: debunked techniques and systemic issues Sponsor messages: NetSuite, Mint Mobile, and The Visitors Origins of forensic techniques and legal precedent Hair microscopy: a discredited technique Bite mark analysis: why it fails Blood spatter analysis: potential vs. practice The role and training of forensic experts Persistence of old methods and new junk science (ShotSpotter) Impact on demographics and capital cases The CSI effect: prosecutor vs. defense perspectives Proposed solutions: FDA-like oversight and blinding Standards for admissible evidence and individualization Conclusion and credits Sponsor message: Mint Mobile Sponsor message: Cure Alzheimer's Fund

More from Short Wave

This gas station drug acts like opioids. It’s getting harder to buy
Nov 20, 2026
How a viral video gave a huge boost to new gene therapy
Nov 18, 2026
How bird poop and manta rays sustain a pristine coral reef
Nov 17, 2026
Are your body clocks off? Meet ‘circadian depression’
Nov 16, 2026
AI could help hospitals diagnose PTSD in real time
Nov 13, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria