A Study in Scarlet: Part Five
Sep 30, 2026 · 1h 2m
Summary
This episode of *A Study in Scarlet* shifts to an omniscient narrator to recount the backstory of the murder. It follows John Ferrier and his daughter Lucy as they are rescued from the desert by a Mormon caravan led by Brigham Young. The story details their settlement in Salt Lake City, where Ferrier becomes wealthy but refuses polygamy, and Lucy falls in love with Jefferson Hope. The narrative culminates in the introduction of the Danite Band, a secret society enforcing the prophet’s will, as Young confronts Ferrier about his lack of wives.
Topics discussed
American Horror Story Season 13 Promo
Introduction to the story's historical context
Historical background of Brigham Young and Mormonism
Description of the arid desert landscape
The haggard wanderer and his search for water
Discovery of the child and her mother's death
The man's backstory and the child's grief
Prayer in the wilderness and the arrival of vultures
Sponsor segment: Depop and viral content
The Mormon caravan approaches the mountains
Mormon scouts discover the sleeping pair
The man and child awaken to the caravan
The man claims the child as his own
Mormon leaders debate accepting the strangers
Decision to take the man and child to Zion
Sponsor segment: Shopify business promotion
Arrival in Utah and establishment of the settlement
John Ferrier's life and Lucy's upbringing
Lucy's ride through the city and cattle stampede
Rescue by Jefferson Hope and their first meeting
Jefferson Hope's courtship of Lucy
The engagement and Jefferson's departure
American Horror Story Season 13 Promo
The Danite Band and secret police in Utah
Brigham Young confronts John Ferrier
Pressure to marry Lucy to a Mormon elder
Ferrier and Lucy plan to escape Utah
Teaser for the next episode
American Horror Story Season 13 Promo
Listen ad-free on Castria