She Wore Black She Wore Black

E220: Theater Gothic with Erin Craig

Sep 17, 2026 · 54m

Summary

Agatha Andrews welcomes Aaron Craig to discuss his new upper YA novel, Our Strange Duet, a retelling of The Phantom of the Opera from Christine’s perspective. The conversation explores the gothic nature of theatrical spaces, comparing haunted theaters to classic gothic houses. They also review several books blending theater and horror, including The Woman in Black, The Prestige, and If We Were Villains, highlighting how stagecraft and performance amplify gothic themes.

Topics discussed

Introduction and Aaron Craig's new book 'Our Strange Duet' Discussion of the book's physical design and cover art History of Phantom adaptations and the appeal of the musical Theaters as haunted houses and repositories of history Decaying grandeur in found spaces and gothic settings Book recommendation: The Woman in Black by Susan Hill Gothic ballets: Giselle and the Vampires of the Ballet Theater of Vampires and the TV series Interview with the Vampire Book recommendation: The Silent Companions by Laura Purcell Book recommendation: The Red Sacrament by Sarah Hockley Book recommendation: Come Knocking by Mike Bohnen Book recommendation: Life She Haunts Me Still by Day Book recommendation: The Prestige by Christopher Priest Book recommendation: The Secret History by Donna Tartt Book recommendation: The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern The rising cost of live theater and music tickets Book recommendation: Shadow Play by Joseph O'Connor Closing remarks and congratulations
Listen ad-free on Castria