Second Date Update Podcasts Second Date Update Podcasts

9 11 26 Hillary & Kirby - Was it Sentimental or Simply a Banana?

Sep 11, 2026 · 6m

Summary

Hillary and Kirby discuss a failed first date where Kirby ghosted Hillary after she panicked over losing a sentimental earring. Kirby reveals she dismissed the incident because the earring looked cheap, while Hillary argues that caring about small things is crucial. The hosts mediate the misunderstanding, but Kirby ultimately declines a second date, leaving Hillary to reflect on the importance of emotional connection.

Topics discussed

Hillary calls in about her first date with Kirby Hosts decide to call Kirby to investigate Sponsorship: Polymarket football trading promo Kirby joins the line and claims the date was horrible Kirby explains he lost a sentimental earring Kirby criticizes Hillary's dismissive 'bummer' text Hillary defends herself, calling it a cheap earring Debate continues: banana comparison and lack of empathy Hosts offer to pay for a second date; Kirby declines Hosts and listeners react to the 'Claire's' comment Facebook giveaway winner announcement Sponsorship: Polymarket football trading promo
Listen ad-free on Castria