E1: Luck, Or Something Like It
Summary
This episode recounts the 1996 discovery of a body in a fishing net off Devon, England, which initially appeared to be a missing local boy. When the victim was identified as Ronald Platt, a Canadian-born British man, detectives struggled to find his connection to the area. The case took a shocking turn when a police officer accidentally knocked on the wrong door and discovered that a man living nearby, known as David Davis, was actually the missing Ronald Platt. The story explores the web of lies and coincidences that led to this revelation.
Topics discussed
Introduction: Sports betting and the show's premise
The concept of luck and the Brixham setting
Craig and John Coppock's fishing day in the roughs
Discovering a body in the fishing nets
The dilemma: reporting the body vs. losing income
Coast Guard response and the missing boy case
Police investigation begins: signs of foul play
Interrogating the crew and the Rolex watch clue
The body is taken to the coroner; show title reveal
Initial search for missing persons fails
Autopsy findings and the decision to scale down
The Rolex serial number leads to R.J. Platt
Tracing Platt's address in Essex and finding a guarantor
Interviewing David Davis, Platt's guarantor
Davis's story: Platt's move to France and money transfer
Confirming identity via army records and brother Brian
The Platt family dynamics and the case goes cold
Recap of sports betting context and transition
The lost phone number and the new car opportunity
The address mix-up: Little London House vs. Farmhouse
Neighbors reveal 'David Davis' is actually Ron Platt
Police realize the suspect is alive and close the episode
Listen ad-free on Castria