rSlash rSlash

r/AITA for Choosing My Cat over Her?

Aug 13, 2026 · 14m

Summary

This r/AmItheButthole episode covers five stories: a man defending his playful sibling rivalry against a toxic boyfriend, a woman ending a date with a gamer who admits to cheating, a wife refusing to replace a chaotic but beloved nanny despite her husband’s objections, a host kicking out guests who let her cat escape, and a couple arguing over unsolicited extra fries. The host judges each scenario, siding with the OPs in most cases while highlighting issues like control, respect, and communication.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: Chime and AT&T Business Wireless Sibling pool prank vs. boyfriend's aggression Boyfriend admits to using aimbots in games Chaotic nanny vs. husband's desire for structure Guests let indoor cat out; host kicks them out Ordering extra fries for girlfriend who steals them Outro and AT&T Business Wireless ad
Listen ad-free on Castria