Revisionist History Revisionist History

The Invention of an Epidemic

Sep 24, 2026 · 48m

Summary

Malcolm Gladwell presents a chapter from his new book, *The American Way of Killing*, arguing that the Second Amendment was drafted to protect Southern slave patrols rather than individual gun rights. He details the 1739 Stono Rebellion in South Carolina, which terrified plantation owners and led to the creation of armed militias for slave control. Using linguistic analysis of 18th-century grammar, Gladwell contends that the Supreme Court’s interpretation in *District of Columbia v. Heller* misreads the amendment’s structure.

Topics discussed

Introduction: ChatGPT and the evolution of the Internet Sponsor: PayPal and the trust of Agentic Commerce Sponsor: Brilliant online math tutoring Book announcement: The American Way of Killing Chapter 2 intro: The Slave Owner's Lament Context: Slaves digging ditches on the Stono River The Stono Rebellion: The attack on Hutchinson's store The rebellion grows and clashes with Lieutenant Governor Bull Sponsor: ChatGPT Work and Henry Ford analogy Sponsor: T-Mobile 5G for multitaskers Sponsor: PayPal and the trust of Agentic Commerce The fear of slave insurrection among Southern planters The Second Amendment and the psychology of gun ownership The patriarchal household and the act of white masculinity Comparison with Mexico's Article 10 on gun rights Grammatical analysis: The being clause and operative clause District of Columbia v. Heller: The Supreme Court case Oral arguments: Parsing the Second Amendment like a classroom Justices debate the relationship between the two clauses The chaos of the oral argument continues The need for 18th-century linguistic context James Madison's precision and the use of linguistic corpora Kari Sullivan's analysis of Madison's prose and being clauses Why the being clause cannot be a standalone thought The Second Amendment is about militias, not individual rights Madison's fear of the Stono Rebellion and militias Sponsor: ChatGPT Work for ambitious projects Sponsor: T-Mobile coverage and reliability Sponsor: PayPal Open for agentic commerce The English origin of militias and the Hue and Cry Militias in the New World and the control of slaves Post-rebellion restrictions on slaves in South Carolina Dunmore's Proclamation and the threat of British freedom The panic among planters during the Revolutionary War Madison's anxiety over the governor's dealings with slaves The Virginia Ratifying Convention of 1788 Federalists vs. Anti-Federalists in Virginia Carl Bogus on the drama of the Virginia Convention Historians' neglect of the Virginia Convention Patrick Henry's fear of a federal government and militia loss Madison's political maneuvering to reassure slave owners The Second Amendment as a political reassurance tool The Supreme Court's grammatical error in Heller The true image of the Second Amendment: Not Minutemen Production credits for The American Way of Killing Sponsor: ChatGPT Work for data and feedback management Sponsors: US Mint coins and Imprints promotional products

More from Revisionist History

Pete Hegseth’s Spiritual Adviser Wants a Christian America | From Reveal
Nov 19, 2026
From The Big Dig: Mitt & Ted
Nov 10, 2026
The $5 Billion Effort to help Secure the World’s Shared Software | Smart Talks with IBM
Oct 29, 2026
Pals, Allies, and Companions | Malcolm Gladwell and Adam Grant Live
Oct 22, 2026
Wolfgang's Law - Part Two
Oct 15, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria