The Staten Island Problem - Part 1: The Mayor vs. the Borough President
Jul 9, 2026 · 37m
More History podcasts
Summary
This episode introduces "The Staten Island Problem," a series exploring the 1990s secessionist movement in Staten Island. Reporter Ben Nadeff-Haffer details the political clash between Mayor David Dinkins and Borough President Guy Molinari, highlighting tensions over the Fresh Kills landfill and police relations. The narrative frames this local conflict as a parable for modern American political division and the fragility of national unity.
Topics discussed
Introduction and sponsor read
Series overview: The Staten Island Problem
Ben's love for NYC and the forgotten borough
Staten Island's identity and secession movement
The stakes of secession and political context
Malcolm Gladwell's move to the NY bureau
David Dinkins: Background and personality
Dinkins' inauguration and vision for NYC
The threat of Staten Island secession
Ad break
The killing of Daniel Garcia in Washington Heights
Police reaction and Dinkins' response
Guy Molinari: Background and political style
The feud: Dinkins and Molinari clash
Ad break
Dinkins arrives in Staten Island
The speech at Borough Hall
Molinari's counter-attacks and Dinkins' struggle
The visit to the Fresh Kills landfill
Reflections on the 90s and modern parallels
Credits and outro
More from Revisionist History
Listen ad-free on Castria