Revisionist History Revisionist History

The Staten Island Problem - Part 5: Revenge of the Forgotten Borough

Aug 6, 2026 · 40m

Summary

Ben Nadler-Haffrey argues that the 193 Staten Island secession movement and Rudy Giuliani’s mayoral victory foreshadowed the rise of Donald Trump. The episode explores how resentment from peripheral communities fueled Giuliani’s “zero tolerance” policies and his alliance with police unions. By examining the Fresh Kills landfill’s transformation, the host connects historical grievances to modern populism, suggesting that ignoring the politics of place leads to authoritarian backlash.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: Grainger, T-Mobile, and Disney Cruise Line 1993 Staten Island Secession Vote Celebration Giuliani's Election and the 'Forgotten Borough' Giuliani and Molinari's Political Alliance The 1992 Police Riot and Giuliani's Role The Politics of Resentment in Rural America Staten Island's Impact on Giuliani's Victory Trump as a Student of Giuliani's Style Parallels Between 1992 NYC and Jan 6, 2021 Fresh Kills Landfill Transformation and Legacy Woody Guthrie's Original 'Staten Island' Lyric Credits and Closing Music

More from Revisionist History

Pete Hegseth’s Spiritual Adviser Wants a Christian America | From Reveal
Nov 19, 2026
From The Big Dig: Mitt & Ted
Nov 10, 2026
The $5 Billion Effort to help Secure the World’s Shared Software | Smart Talks with IBM
Oct 29, 2026
Pals, Allies, and Companions | Malcolm Gladwell and Adam Grant Live
Oct 22, 2026
Wolfgang's Law - Part Two
Oct 15, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria