Revisionist History: The Staten Island Problem Revisionist History: The Staten Island Problem

The Trust Diagnosis

May 21, 2026

Summary

Malcolm Gladwell interviews crisis communications expert Dan, who applied his professional instincts to navigate a misdiagnosed prostate cancer case. After initial doctors deemed surgery futile, Dan trusted his judgment to seek second opinions, ultimately finding a surgeon willing to operate. The episode explores how misplaced trust in flawed data can be overcome by relying on experience, intuition, and rigorous personal analysis to make life-altering decisions.

Topics discussed

PayPal Open sponsorship and introduction Malcolm Gladwell's cancer diagnosis story Introduction of Dan and crisis communications The nature of trust in high-stakes crises Gladwell's medical crisis and conflicting advice Applying crisis management skills to health decisions Choosing a surgeon and the surgery outcome Three layers of trust and final reflections
Listen ad-free on Castria