2026’s Most WTF Trial: Isaac Apodaca & The Bloody Sword Murder | #477
Nov 19, 2026 · 1h 6m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode of *Red Handed* examines the 2022 murder of Grace Jennings in Santa Fe, where her ex-girlfriend Kiara McCulley stabbed her to death with a sword. The hosts analyze the bizarre digital trail of text messages between Kiara and her boyfriend, Isaac Apodoka, who allegedly manipulated her into committing the act by claiming to be an archangel leading a secret vigilante group. The discussion highlights the legal complexities of prosecuting Isaac for first-degree murder based on coercion and the influence of TikTok-era mental health trends on the defendants’ narratives.
Topics discussed
Introduction: The murder of Grace Jennings
Hosts introduce the case and digital trail
Casual banter and host introductions
Police arrival and initial scene discovery
Autopsy details and physical evidence
Interrogation of Kiara and Isaac
The complex relationship triangle
Production notes and trial timing issues
Discussion on the bizarre nature of the crime
Advice to listeners on visualizing the cast
Grace's visit to the McCulley house
Detective Vigil's investigation into the night
Kiara's confession of hatred for Grace
Kiara's admission of murder fantasies
Kiara's vague memory of the murder morning
Introduction of the DID defense
Kiara's claim of multiple personalities
Descriptions of Kiara's alleged alters
Overview of Dissociative Identity Disorder
Criticism of social media's impact on DID
Study linking TikTok to self-diagnosed disorders
Personal anecdotes on pandemic effects on youth
Critique of removing children from school
Impact on adolescent girls specifically
Rise in malingering and faking conditions
Promotion of the Not Today podcast
Differences between real and faked DID cases
Kiara's claim of Isaac's involvement
The conspiracy theory and text messages
Social media game and Archangel Gabriel
Discussion on biblical archangels and TikTok
The 'Ghost' organization and pedo-hunting claims
Concerns about declining critical thinking
Isaac's manipulation and initiation rituals
Isaac's defense: No sex, just peer pressure
Isaac's account of finding the body
Analysis of the text messages and pet names
Isaac's encouragement and exploitation of alters
Reading damning text messages from Isaac
Isaac's denial despite digital evidence
Critique of Isaac's low-effort defense
Kiara's irrational behavior post-murder
Isaac's Google searches and departure
Isaac's claim of being a peacemaker
Interrogation of Isaac on specific texts
Discussion on the state of the bed
Reading texts about cleaning up the mess
Isaac's shifting blame to Kiara
Isaac's final attempt at victimhood
Charges against Kiara and competency ruling
Prosecution's stance on Isaac's culpability
Legal definition of coercion
Isaac's plea deal and lawyer resignation
Tangential discussion on Jane Eyre
Kiara's guilty plea and charge reduction
Kiara's obligation to testify against Isaac
Upgraded charges for Isaac
Defense strategy for Isaac's trial
Defense arguments: Alibi and lack of force
Cross-examination of Detective Vigil
Defense on the sword and LARPing interests
Defense claim of wiped phone evidence
Critique of defense lawyer's performance
Kiara's testimony on past abuse
Kiara's testimony on mental manipulation
Kiara's admission on DID and buried memories
Kiara's motivation to believe in Ghost
Kiara's account of the murder moment
Expert testimony on the couple's dynamic
Verdict: Isaac found guilty
Discussion on sentencing disparities
Hosts' final thoughts on Kiara's role
Reflection on Grace Jennings as the victim
More from RedHanded
Listen ad-free on Castria