Mel's Hole | The Supernatural Existence of This Backyard Bottomless Pit
Jul 13, 2026 · 1h 6m
Summary
Hosts Trevor Collins and Alfredo Diaz explore the urban legend of Mel’s Hole, a purported bottomless pit in Washington state. They detail caller Mel Waters’ escalating claims of paranormal phenomena, including transmuting metals and resurrected pets, which allegedly prompted a government cover-up. The episode analyzes the story’s scientific implausibility versus its mysterious satellite imagery and Waters’ subsequent disappearance.
Topics discussed
Sponsors and episode introduction
Anniversary stream recap and merch update
Mel's Hole overview and the fishing line measurement
Scientific analysis of the fishing line depth claim
Sponsor segment: Rocket Money
Strange phenomena: dogs, radio static, and time travel
Alchemical transmutation theories
Government threats and the $3 million buyout
Satellite imagery and the white boxes mystery
Proposed drone and fishing line retrieval plans
Mel Waters' disappearance and return to the US
Sponsor segment: Wine delivery service
Geological and physical impossibility of the hole
Alien and portal theories for the mystery
Final thoughts and listener submission call
Task force updates and closing remarks
Listen ad-free on Castria