True Crime Time For October 17, 2026 | The Hillside Stranglers, Al Capone & a Botched Execution That Shocked Tennessee
Summary
Host Woody Overton discusses the Hillside Stranglers, Al Capone’s conviction, and the 2002 Beltway sniper case. The episode focuses heavily on the botched execution of Tennessee inmate Christina Pike, detailing the chaotic 911 response and her survival after two lethal doses. Overton contrasts Pike’s ordeal with the brutal torture of her victim, Colleen Slimer, while also reviewing the historical punishment of being hanged, drawn, and quartered.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: Burn Apparel, Ernesta, and Sherwin-Williams
Intro, Hurricane Helene update, and travel plans
The Hillside Stranglers: Angelo Buono and Kenneth Bianchi
Al Capone's conviction and the Alcatraz legend
Beltway Sniper case: Fingerprint evidence breakthrough
Sponsors: Vented, BetterHelp, and True Age Test
Assassination of Israeli Tourism Minister Rehavam Zevi
Execution of Regicides and the history of drawing and quartering
Christina Pike's botched execution and survival
Sponsors: Ernesta and Sherwin-Williams
Legal fallout and Pike's original crime details
Analysis of 911 dispatch calls during the failed execution
Host's perspective on death penalty and closing remarks
Sponsor: CFP Financial Professionals
Listen ad-free on Castria