The hosts discuss a listener’s story about loving her 150-year-old Pennsylvania home despite terrifying hauntings, including disembodied voices, a dark presence, and friends seeing floating heads. They share personal anecdotes about growing up in haunted houses and the social awkwardness of hosting sleepovers. The episode concludes with a caller describing a terrifying hallucination of a scorpion-human hybrid while under the influence, which the hosts debate as either a bad trip or a paranormal encounter.