She Was Faking The Whole Thing // The Sharee Miller Murder Story
Summary
This episode details the true crime story of Cherie, a woman who manipulated Jerry into believing she was pregnant with his children and that her husband, Bruce, was an abusive mafia boss. Cherie orchestrated a plot to have Jerry kill Bruce, who was actually innocent, leading to his murder. After realizing Cherie had only used him, Jerry confessed to the crime and took his own life, leaving behind evidence that led to Cherie's arrest and eventual conviction for life in prison.
Topics discussed
Cherie's online infidelity and aliases
Meeting Jerry and the initial affair
The long-distance relationship and meetings
Manipulation: Faking abuse and first pregnancy
Fake sonograms and the lost baby lie
The twins lie and the murder plot
The shooting of Bruce
Police investigation and false suspect
Jerry's realization and guilt
The confession briefcase and Jerry's death
Cherie's arrest and life sentence
Listen ad-free on Castria