The Buried Bodies Case
Oct 30, 2026 · 49m
More History podcasts · More Science podcasts
Summary
This episode explores the 1973 "Buried Bodies" case, where attorneys Frank Armani and Francis Belgy defended Robert Garrow, a convicted murderer who confessed to killing two missing girls. The story examines the intense moral conflict between a lawyer's duty of confidentiality and the desire to provide closure to the victims' families. Through interviews with Armani, legal experts, and a victim's mother, the episode highlights the personal toll of upholding legal ethics and why this case remains a foundational lesson in legal responsibility.
Topics discussed
Sponsors and introduction to the story
Meet the experts: Lisa Lerman and Brenna Farrell
Reporter Jim Tracy and the 1973 camping trip
The attack: Campers tied up and threatened
The murder of Philip Domblowski
The escape and the start of the manhunt
Public panic and the state-wide search
Garrow's capture and hospitalization
The missing girl and the legal dilemma
Introduction to attorney Frank Armani
Armani's background and meeting Garrow
Garrow's prior charges and flight
Armani appointed as public defender
Recruiting co-counsel Belji
First meeting with Garrow in the hospital
Police lip-reading and legal ethics
The duty of confidentiality and trust
Persuading Garrow to cooperate
Sponsor break: Capital One
Sponsor break: A Ghost in Your Ear
Content warning and return to the story
The missing girls: Susan Petz and Alicia Hawk
Garrow's confession and the lawyers' reaction
The location: An abandoned mine shaft
Driving to the mine and entering the forest
Searching for the cave entrance
Discovering the bodies in the mine
The ethical dilemma: To tell or not to tell
Legal analysis of the situation
The role of the defense attorney
Personal connections to the victims
Sponsor break: Capital One
Sponsor break: A Ghost in Your Ear
Sponsor break: AT&T and Your Turn
The plea bargain proposal
Meeting with the DA and state police
The collapse of the deal
Susan Petz's father visits Armani
Armani's personal loss and empathy
Preparing for trial and the insanity defense
Armani's psychological burden
Armani's decision to stay silent
The trial begins: Garrow on the stand
Garrow's testimony and life story
The slip-up: Revealing the bodies
Public outrage and media backlash
Garrow's conviction and sentencing
Threats of criminal charges against lawyers
Charges dropped and ethical vindication
Armani as a real-life Atticus Finch
The case in law schools today
Why the case is a teaching touchstone
Interview with Roberta Petz
Roberta's reaction to the law school teaching
The family's experience during the search
Criticism of the lawyer's actions
Long-term emotional impact on the family
Reflections on the tragedy
Moment of silence
Field recording from the mine
Credits and acknowledgments
Listener message from London
Staff credits
Foundational support credits
More from Radiolab
Listen ad-free on Castria