Radiolab Radiolab

The Buried Bodies Case

Oct 30, 2026 · 49m

Summary

This episode explores the 1973 "Buried Bodies" case, where attorneys Frank Armani and Francis Belgy defended Robert Garrow, a convicted murderer who confessed to killing two missing girls. The story examines the intense moral conflict between a lawyer's duty of confidentiality and the desire to provide closure to the victims' families. Through interviews with Armani, legal experts, and a victim's mother, the episode highlights the personal toll of upholding legal ethics and why this case remains a foundational lesson in legal responsibility.

Topics discussed

Sponsors and introduction to the story Meet the experts: Lisa Lerman and Brenna Farrell Reporter Jim Tracy and the 1973 camping trip The attack: Campers tied up and threatened The murder of Philip Domblowski The escape and the start of the manhunt Public panic and the state-wide search Garrow's capture and hospitalization The missing girl and the legal dilemma Introduction to attorney Frank Armani Armani's background and meeting Garrow Garrow's prior charges and flight Armani appointed as public defender Recruiting co-counsel Belji First meeting with Garrow in the hospital Police lip-reading and legal ethics The duty of confidentiality and trust Persuading Garrow to cooperate Sponsor break: Capital One Sponsor break: A Ghost in Your Ear Content warning and return to the story The missing girls: Susan Petz and Alicia Hawk Garrow's confession and the lawyers' reaction The location: An abandoned mine shaft Driving to the mine and entering the forest Searching for the cave entrance Discovering the bodies in the mine The ethical dilemma: To tell or not to tell Legal analysis of the situation The role of the defense attorney Personal connections to the victims Sponsor break: Capital One Sponsor break: A Ghost in Your Ear Sponsor break: AT&T and Your Turn The plea bargain proposal Meeting with the DA and state police The collapse of the deal Susan Petz's father visits Armani Armani's personal loss and empathy Preparing for trial and the insanity defense Armani's psychological burden Armani's decision to stay silent The trial begins: Garrow on the stand Garrow's testimony and life story The slip-up: Revealing the bodies Public outrage and media backlash Garrow's conviction and sentencing Threats of criminal charges against lawyers Charges dropped and ethical vindication Armani as a real-life Atticus Finch The case in law schools today Why the case is a teaching touchstone Interview with Roberta Petz Roberta's reaction to the law school teaching The family's experience during the search Criticism of the lawyer's actions Long-term emotional impact on the family Reflections on the tragedy Moment of silence Field recording from the mine Credits and acknowledgments Listener message from London Staff credits Foundational support credits

More from Radiolab

Terminial Delirium
Nov 20, 2026
There and Back Again
Nov 13, 2026
More Perfect: Cruel and Unusual
Nov 6, 2026
Octomom
Oct 23, 2026
The Smell of Hell
Oct 16, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria