AI Is Making Us All Dumber
May 12, 2026
Summary
Host Ed Elson welcomes Cal Newport and Derek Thompson to discuss whether AI is diminishing human intelligence. They argue that outsourcing writing and deep reading to AI atrophies critical thinking skills, akin to skipping weightlifting in favor of a forklift. The experts warn this trend threatens economic productivity and individual success, advocating for educational reforms like oral exams to restore cognitive fitness.
Topics discussed
Sponsorship: Indeed Sponsored Jobs
Headlines: Netflix MMA, Met Gala, and Market Vitals
The Question: Is AI Making Us Dumber?
Cal Newport on Cognitive Fitness and Deep Work
Derek Thompson on AI Summaries and Lost Nuance
The Erosion of Deep Thinking Skills
AI vs. Traditional Technology: A False Equivalence
Sponsors: Hostinger, Windows 11, and Shopify
AI in Education: Cheating vs. Augmentation
Solutions: Oral Exams and the Oxford Model
National Security and Global Cognitive Competition
The Productivity Paradox in the Modern Workplace
Gen Z, Materialism, and Cognitive Time Under Tension
The Danger of a Non-Thinking Generation
Career Advice: Deep Work as Economic Value
Outro and Credits
Listen ad-free on Castria