Journalist Jane McSorley recounts her four-year investigation into a bizarre case of mistaken identity involving a man arrested in a Glasgow COVID ward. US authorities claimed he was fugitive Nicholas Rossi, wanted for rape in Utah, while he insisted he was innocent Irishman Arthur Knight. The episode details McSorley’s initial discovery of the story and her striking first encounter with the defendant at an Edinburgh court hearing. She describes his disheveled appearance and disruptive behavior during the bail hearing, setting the stage for a complex mystery.