Planet Money Planet Money

We almost had a smartphone in the 90s. Why did it fail?

Jun 26, 2026 · 26m

Summary

This episode explores the rise and fall of General Magic, a 1990s startup that built a smartphone-like device two decades before the iPhone. Despite having top talent and unlimited funding, the company failed due to a lack of constraints, clear customer focus, and deadlines. Hosts interview former engineer Tony Fidel and author David Epstein, who argue that limits foster creativity. The story contrasts General Magic’s chaos with the disciplined, constraint-driven success of Apple’s iPod and iPhone.

Topics discussed

Sponsor message from Thumbtack Introduction: Tony Fidel and the pre-iPhone smartphone Planet Money intro and sponsor messages General Magic: The dream team with unlimited resources The failure of the Sony Magic Link device Lesson 1: Lack of a clear customer or problem Lesson 2: Too much money and scope creep Lesson 3: No deadlines or management constraints Sponsor messages from Cook Unity, Grainger, and ActiveCampaign Tony Fidel applies constraints to build the iPod The psychology of constraints and additive bias Listener call to action and closing credits

More from Planet Money

You Can Seize Everything (The U.S. is reviving pirate law)
Nov 20, 2026
Two ways big bets on data centers might affect you (Two Indicators)
Nov 18, 2026
Are wildfires making the future uninsurable?
Nov 13, 2026
How bodegas led to the Yemeni coffeehouse explosion
Nov 11, 2026
Inside the insurance industry’s destruction lab
Nov 6, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria