Housing Is a Market Power Problem (with Sandeep Vaheesan & Brian Callaci)
Summary
Nick Hanauer discusses the U.S. housing crisis with Open Markets Institute’s Brian Kalachi and Sandeep Vahezen, arguing that market deregulation alone is insufficient to fix affordability. They contend that landlord market power, exemplified by the RealPage algorithm, and the lack of a robust public housing option drive high rents. The episode advocates for a combination of antitrust enforcement, rent controls, and a federal public housing authority to provide competitive discipline and stability for middle-income households.
Topics discussed
Introduction: The complexity of the housing crisis
Welcome to Pitchfork Economics
Why housing is different from other markets
Guest introductions: Brian Kahachi and Sandeep Vaheesan
Summary of the HBR article: Beyond supply-side fixes
The YIMBY argument: Zoning and the hermit crab effect
Evidence on upzoning and its limited impact on supply
Public sector role: Counter-cyclical construction and post-2008 slump
RealPage and algorithmic rent-setting
Landlord market power and monopsony dynamics
Policy solutions: Rent control and tenant protections
The case for a federal public housing authority
Historical context: New Deal housing vs. modern failures
Why public housing was designed to fail and racial exclusion
Defining social housing and the importance of stability
Flexible rent controls and good cause eviction
Private restrictive covenants and HOA limitations
Land value, sprawl, and market profit extraction
Demand-side factors: Wealth concentration and regional inequality
Closing thoughts: Mobilizing government capacity for housing
Listen ad-free on Castria