The Fish
Summary
Host Delia D'Ambra recounts the 1940 Waterville, Minnesota triple homicide where fish dealer Bryant Baumgardner shot three game wardens enforcing bullhead fishing laws. The episode details the tense investigation into illegal commercial fishing, the violent confrontation, and Baumgardner’s subsequent suicide. It explores the aftermath, including community hostility toward the officers and legislative changes allowing wardens to carry firearms.
Topics discussed
Introduction to Waterville, MN and the Bullhead Capital
Game Wardens and Illegal Bullhead Fishing Laws
The Investigation of Bryant Baumgardner
Ad Break: Quince Home Essentials
The Triple Homicide and Suicide at the Fish Barn
Aftermath: Inquest, Public Reaction, and Policy Changes
Legacy of the Victims and Bryant's Son Earl
Memorial Plaque and Final Reflections on the Case
Outro and Sponsor Read for Dark Down East
Listen ad-free on Castria