The Plan
Summary
This episode details the 2021 murder of Matthew Dunmire in Cuyahoga Valley National Park by Chelsea Perkins, who lured him to the woods and shot him. Investigators used GPS data, DNA evidence, and digital footprints to link Perkins to the crime, uncovering a motive rooted in a prior sexual assault allegation. The case also highlights a tragic subplot where Dunmire’s parents mistakenly shot an innocent woman in a failed revenge attempt. Perkins eventually pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and received a 22.5-year sentence.
Topics discussed
Introduction to Park Predators and the Cuyahoga Valley case
Discovery of Matthew Dunmire's body in the park
Investigation tracks Matthew's last movements and vehicle
Sponsor segment: Quints clothing and accessories
Sponsor segment: So Supernatural podcast promo
GPS data reveals Chelsea Perkins as a suspect
Forensic evidence links Chelsea to the murder weapon
Chelsea's arrest and initial court proceedings
Uncovering the history between Matthew and Chelsea
Bond hearing arguments and legal delays
Matthew's parents' vigilante attack and Chelsea's sentencing
Chelsea's prison life, digital evidence, and conclusion
Listen ad-free on Castria